Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
A quiet curving road beside a harvested field and autumn trees, with a cream farmhouse partly visible at the edge of the landscape.

What the Mount Pleasant Road Warehouse Hearing Means for Cloverleaf Road

November 19, 2026

The 106.5-acre field at 2843 Mount Pleasant Road, across the road from Greiner Industries, is back before the Mount Joy Township Zoning Hearing Board. The new plan calls for three industrial buildings totaling more than 1.2 million square feet. The township's own traffic reviewer has looked at it. His October 13, 2026 letter shows that the Cloverleaf Road and Schwanger Road intersection fails at rush hour whether or not anything is built on that field. Most of the other roadwork the plan counts on comes from the township's capital improvement plan.

If you drive Cloverleaf Road or use the Route 283 ramps every day, what happens there depends on the board's decision and also on the road projects the township schedules.

Why a Rezoned Farm Field Is Still Before the Zoning Board

This is the second try at warehouses on this tract. As LNP | LancasterOnline reported, Panattoni Development Co. proposed a 1-million-square-foot warehouse here. The zoning hearing board turned it down in July 2023, citing traffic and possible effects on the surrounding neighborhood. Panattoni appealed and later dropped the appeal.

The applicant this time is the landowner, Franklin Greiner Jr., founder of Greiner Industries. Blue Ball-based Ethos Development drew up the plans. Ethos President Matt Nunn told LNP that Ethos would become the owner if the approvals come through.

Many neighbors are surprised the case is being heard at all. At a Nov. 17 meeting, days after the application discussed below was filed, the township supervisors voted unanimously to rezone the tract from light industrial back to agricultural. The land had been agricultural until 2016. LNP reported that at that meeting, Supervisor Debra Dupler called the Panattoni experience "horrible." Supervisor David Sweigart said he favored an industrial use for the property, smaller than Panattoni's. Chris Naylor, an attorney for Greiner, called the rezoning "illegal reverse spot zoning."

The timing explains it. The special exception application was filed on November 13, 2025, while the light industrial zoning was still in effect, so the board has to consider the industrial plan. Greiner's separate challenge to the rezoning is on hold until the special exception hearing ends.

The application asks for three things. It seeks special exceptions for industrial buildings over the township's 50,000-square-foot limit and for an industrial park. It also asks for more time: three years instead of one to get a zoning permit, and four years instead of two to finish construction.

A Hearing Expected to Take Three Meetings

Before the first session in April, LNP reported that the hearing was expected to take three meetings. The township's case page now lists eleven dates. Sessions have moved between Gibble Auditorium at Elizabethtown College, the Elizabethtown Area Middle School auditorium on East High Street, and the township meeting room at 8853 Elizabethtown Road. The record has grown in stages:

  1. April 14. The board accepted the neighboring residents as parties. Testimony began with Nunn, who described the largest building as warehouse-only and the other two as mainly warehousing, with a list of excluded uses.
  2. April 30 and June 1. Both dates were continued without testimony. The applicant agreed to extend the statutory hearing timeframe.
  3. June 11. Cross-examination covered truck routing, the unnamed tenants, warehouse versus light industrial uses, utilities, noise and the requested time extension.
  4. July 16. Questioning turned to water and sewer capacity. Civil engineer Joshua Hoffman testified that the original authority letters did not guarantee or reserve capacity.
  5. September 17. Updated letters were entered. The sewer authority's response depends on upgrades to the Trunk A Interceptor and a pump station, which the applicant said it would build if a residential developer did not. Testimony also covered landscaping buffers and a wetland the applicant proposes to fill, subject to permits and mitigation.
  6. September 22 through November 18. Five more sessions were scheduled. The tenth was November 12 in the township meeting room, and the eleventh was set for November 18.

The traffic material added in this last stretch is the part most residents will feel.

The Traffic Numbers, Side by Side

The applicant's engineer, Traffic Planning and Design, revised its traffic impact study on September 8, 2026. Christopher E. Schwab of Transportation Resource Group, the township's reviewer, responded on October 13 with two scenarios.

Scenario AM peak trips PM peak trips Daily trips Daily truck trips
Applicant's proposed land-use codes 199 229 2,422 383
All three buildings as warehousing 223 259 2,410 509

Total daily trips barely change between the two scenarios, but daily truck trips rise by 126 when all three buildings are treated as warehouses. That difference connects to testimony from June. Nunn said the two smaller buildings could serve local businesses looking to expand or relocate. He also agreed that any tenant would have to stay within the warehouse traffic projections.

For comparison, an automated traffic recorder in November 2025 counted about 914 vehicles on an average weekday on Mount Pleasant Road itself. An earlier count showed 881. The plan is designed to keep trucks off that road. All truck traffic would use a new Archers Lane linking Mount Pleasant Road to Steel Way. The western driveway would have tight curb radii so trucks can't turn there, and the eastern driveway would be for cars only. Schwab agreed with the Archers Lane connection, which is already on the township's Official Map. Mount Pleasant Road is a state road. Hoffman testified that PennDOT would review the access there and that truck restrictions on it would be pursued after zoning.

The Intersection That Fails Either Way

From Steel Way, trucks would reach Cloverleaf Road and the Route 283 interchange. The applicant's study relies on a township ordinance provision: if needed road improvements are already in the township's Transportation Capital Improvements Plan, the applicant may treat them as "constructed by others." The study assumes these projects are done by its 2030 opening year:

  • A new signal, northbound and southbound left-turn lanes, and a new Route 283 westbound ramp at Cloverleaf Road and Steel Way, creating a four-way intersection
  • Removal of the signal at the Route 283 west ramps, with the westbound ramp changed to right turns only
  • A new signal at the Route 283 east ramps
  • Closure of the Merts Drive intersection
  • Signal retiming at Cloverleaf Road and Schwanger Road

With all of that built, every studied intersection works acceptably except Cloverleaf and Schwanger. There, northbound and southbound traffic falls to level of service F during the morning peak, and southbound traffic does too in the evening. Bringing it up to level of service D would take a second through lane in each direction. The study doesn't propose those lanes because they would be needed with or without the warehouses.

Schwab also warned that the capital projects might not all be finished before the buildings open. The study's fallback includes a northbound right-turn lane at Steel Way, signal changes at the ramps and at Schwanger, and a ban on left turns from Merts Drive. Even with those, the reviewer found failing or deficient movements at the Route 283 west ramps and at Schwanger. The April LNP preview described three roundabouts on Cloverleaf Road. The current study treats roundabouts at the Route 283 ramps as an alternative design. The applicant has said it would consider voluntary contributions beyond the required fees, and Schwab recommended talks with the township.

What Each Side Has Put on the Record

Most of the arguments come down to how close the site is to homes. At the April hearing, as LNP | LancasterOnline reported, the developer said the buildings would fit with similar businesses along Mount Pleasant Road. William Cluck, the attorney representing neighbors, said that view downplays surrounding homes, some less than 600 feet away. The April minutes record the developer's comparisons to Greiner Industries and Hershey Excavating, which are both on light industrial land.

On noise, the applicant's sound study notes that the township ordinance has no numeric sound limit. It uses the EPA's recommended 55 dBA day-night average as its benchmark. It modeled peak traffic, loading, backup alarms, overnight operations and rooftop HVAC running at full load, and it concludes the project should meet that benchmark.

WGAL's September coverage found mixed views. Neighbors raised traffic, environmental effects, resource use, noise and the loss of farmland. One nearby resident supported the project for its potential tax revenue and industry.

What Comes After the Last Hearing

According to LNP, the board has to issue its decision within 45 days of the final hearing. Greiner's challenge to the agricultural rezoning has been on hold until the special exception hearing ends. Even with zoning approval, the road work would go through PennDOT's highway occupancy permit process. The applicant's engineer said new traffic counts may be taken at that stage if PennDOT or the township asks for them. The improvement map the applicant submitted in September is labeled conceptual and not for construction.

The township posts every hearing date, the minutes and the exhibits on its 2843 Mount Pleasant Road case page. That includes the October 13 traffic review letter and the original traffic impact study. The Cloverleaf Road projects listed above are the township's own, so they will come up again at supervisors' meetings whatever the zoning board decides.

If you live near Cloverleaf Road or Mount Pleasant Road and want to understand how this case and the planned road work could affect your home's value, The John Smith Team can help. We follow Mount Joy Township closely. Request a Free Home Valuation and we'll walk you through what we're seeing on your street.

Follow Us On Instagram